CLICK to enlarge
 
Disecting Photos

Critical Performance: The purpose is to eliminate our "like-dislike" "good-bad" reflex and take the time to more fully look at and respond to the work. This process can't be learned in a day - it's a skill to be developed over a lifetime.

  • description (things): lines, shapes, colors, textures - not naming (clouds, hands, trucks)
  • analysis (relationships): repetition, depth, focus (sweet spot), alignment
  • interpretation (meaning):
  • judgment (importance):

Edmund Burke Feldman developed this approach in Varieties of Visual Experience: Art as Image and Idea (1971).

 

CLICK to enlarge

 

In Class DESCRIPTION Exercise:

  1. Click and Look at the above for one full minute. Try not to judge or think in words ;-) Try not to think at all. Don't worry. Focus your attention.
  2. For 2 minutes: List the things (lines, shapes, colors, textures) that you observe. Just write - don't evaluate what you are writing. No one else will ever see your list.
  3. Set the paper aside.
  4. Next we will repeat the actitivy as a group... Leslye will record responses.
  5. Re-read your list. Cross out those items that name a subject, or indicate a judgment.

 

   
 
Suggested Readings:
 
Basic approach for adults with photos: www.whyte.org/lens/seeing.html
Overall Process: www.k-state.edu/bma/exhib/2004/photo-curriculum/pdfs/aesthetic-criticism.pdf

 
Judging shows: Leslye's statement
 

Further Study:

Winter Red source file
   

 

Winter Red artwork (large)

 
 
||